![BMO Commercial Banking](https://commercial.bmo.com/static/img/BMO-ca-logo.jpg)
Canadian Housing Liftoff or Letdown?
-
bookmark
-
print
![Living homes in Canada.](https://commercial.bmo.com/media/filer_public/1b/6a/1b6ac938-49fe-4165-ace0-ff3d99d98358/istock-502456176_0_71_1256_767.jpg)
- Keywords:
![Living homes in Canada](https://commercial.bmo.com/media/filer_public/1b/6a/1b6ac938-49fe-4165-ace0-ff3d99d98358/istock-502456176_0_71_1256_767.jpg)
![Living homes in Canada](https://commercial.bmo.com/media/filer_public/1b/6a/1b6ac938-49fe-4165-ace0-ff3d99d98358/istock-502456176_0_71_1256_767.jpg)
The Bank of Canada’s rate cut marks a key moment in this cycle, and especially so in the housing and mortgage markets. Most market participants have been eagerly awaiting this cut, and there will surely be a psychological boost now that the peak of this rate cycle has most likely been set. But, at the same time, a 25 bp trim to variable rates from 23-year highs is very little actual relief when most borrowers have already moved to lower fixed-rate mortgages.
Buyers have been mostly absent from the variable-mortgage market given much higher rates in that space. Over the latest 12 months, variable-rate mortgages have made up less than 10% of new lending, with most buyers borrowing at 5- year or shorter-term fixed. That makes sense from an affordability and qualification perspective given that those rates are a good 125 bps lower. It also means that, if the market is mostly operating on fixed rates right now, this week’s move doesn’t alter the calculus much even if it does provide a psychological boost. Canadian 5-year GoC yields are already down a full percentage point from the October 2023 high, which has helped pull down most 5-year fixed rates to, or below, 5%. There is already easing priced into the housing market system. Interestingly, 5-year GoC yields ended the week little changed from pre-BoC levels.
Even with the correction in home prices and the recent decline in fixed mortgage rates, affordability is still strained. Immediately returning affordability to pre-COVID levels would require either mortgage rates backing down to slightly below 4%; a 12% decline in home prices; or a like-sized jump in income levels—in reality, some combination of all three plays out over time. But the point here is that valuations are still a limiter on how quickly the market can rebound in the short term.
With that in mind, it’s no wonder that activity has been quiet while supply has been building this spring. Sales in Toronto and Vancouver were each down roughly 20% y/y in May, while active listings were up significantly—83% higher than a year ago in Toronto and 46% in Vancouver. The number of active condo listings in Toronto has never been higher, and single-detached listings are approaching post-GFC highs. Either everyone was waiting for confirmation from the Bank of Canada (we’ll see in the coming weeks), or the homebuying/investing calculus still doesn’t quite work. Our view has been that growing inventory and little actual mortgage-rate relief will keep the market from really taking off at this stage.
Finally, we’re not in the business of giving financial advice, and every borrower has a different risk appetite. But with the easing cycle now here, the variable vs. fixed question is arising again. The complication is that fixed rates still offer about 125 bps of value relative to variable, and many will need that buffer to qualify at current price levels. Hesitancy to lock in for 5 years at the start of easing cycle is also understood, which might leave 2- and 3-year fixed as the sweet spot for rate value: less term and the possibility of rolling into lower rates sooner. Indeed, we’d probably argue that the first 75-to-100 bps of easing should be relatively straightforward, but the next leg of the cycle back toward neutral policy rates (and therefore variable mortgage rates) could become more complicated by factors such as stubborn U.S. inflation and the Federal Reserve’s ability to ease into, and through, 2025.
Robert has been with the Bank of Montreal since 2006. He plays a key role in analyzing economic, fiscal and real estate trends in Canada. Robert regularly contribut…(..)
View Full Profile >The Bank of Canada’s rate cut marks a key moment in this cycle, and especially so in the housing and mortgage markets. Most market participants have been eagerly awaiting this cut, and there will surely be a psychological boost now that the peak of this rate cycle has most likely been set. But, at the same time, a 25 bp trim to variable rates from 23-year highs is very little actual relief when most borrowers have already moved to lower fixed-rate mortgages.
Buyers have been mostly absent from the variable-mortgage market given much higher rates in that space. Over the latest 12 months, variable-rate mortgages have made up less than 10% of new lending, with most buyers borrowing at 5- year or shorter-term fixed. That makes sense from an affordability and qualification perspective given that those rates are a good 125 bps lower. It also means that, if the market is mostly operating on fixed rates right now, this week’s move doesn’t alter the calculus much even if it does provide a psychological boost. Canadian 5-year GoC yields are already down a full percentage point from the October 2023 high, which has helped pull down most 5-year fixed rates to, or below, 5%. There is already easing priced into the housing market system. Interestingly, 5-year GoC yields ended the week little changed from pre-BoC levels.
Even with the correction in home prices and the recent decline in fixed mortgage rates, affordability is still strained. Immediately returning affordability to pre-COVID levels would require either mortgage rates backing down to slightly below 4%; a 12% decline in home prices; or a like-sized jump in income levels—in reality, some combination of all three plays out over time. But the point here is that valuations are still a limiter on how quickly the market can rebound in the short term.
With that in mind, it’s no wonder that activity has been quiet while supply has been building this spring. Sales in Toronto and Vancouver were each down roughly 20% y/y in May, while active listings were up significantly—83% higher than a year ago in Toronto and 46% in Vancouver. The number of active condo listings in Toronto has never been higher, and single-detached listings are approaching post-GFC highs. Either everyone was waiting for confirmation from the Bank of Canada (we’ll see in the coming weeks), or the homebuying/investing calculus still doesn’t quite work. Our view has been that growing inventory and little actual mortgage-rate relief will keep the market from really taking off at this stage.
Finally, we’re not in the business of giving financial advice, and every borrower has a different risk appetite. But with the easing cycle now here, the variable vs. fixed question is arising again. The complication is that fixed rates still offer about 125 bps of value relative to variable, and many will need that buffer to qualify at current price levels. Hesitancy to lock in for 5 years at the start of easing cycle is also understood, which might leave 2- and 3-year fixed as the sweet spot for rate value: less term and the possibility of rolling into lower rates sooner. Indeed, we’d probably argue that the first 75-to-100 bps of easing should be relatively straightforward, but the next leg of the cycle back toward neutral policy rates (and therefore variable mortgage rates) could become more complicated by factors such as stubborn U.S. inflation and the Federal Reserve’s ability to ease into, and through, 2025.
Related Insights
Tell us three simple things to
customize your experience
![search 1](https://commercial.bmo.com/media/filer_public/ef/77/ef770d21-7a65-4a56-8045-c9be3b8f4955/custom-search-image-1.jpg)
![search 2](https://commercial.bmo.com/media/filer_public/96/76/96762654-f486-4df4-9ab6-f413d85b6305/2_women_talking_for_banker_widget_istock-677809868_cropped.jpg)
![search 1](https://commercial.bmo.com/media/filer_public/ef/77/ef770d21-7a65-4a56-8045-c9be3b8f4955/custom-search-image-1.jpg)
![search 2](https://commercial.bmo.com/media/filer_public/96/76/96762654-f486-4df4-9ab6-f413d85b6305/2_women_talking_for_banker_widget_istock-677809868_cropped.jpg)
![search 1](https://commercial.bmo.com/media/filer_public/ef/77/ef770d21-7a65-4a56-8045-c9be3b8f4955/custom-search-image-1.jpg)
![search 2](https://commercial.bmo.com/media/filer_public/96/76/96762654-f486-4df4-9ab6-f413d85b6305/2_women_talking_for_banker_widget_istock-677809868_cropped.jpg)
Commercial
Commercial
-
Who We Are
-
Industry Expertise
- Engineering & Construction
- Engineering & Construction
- Agriculture
- Agriculture
- Trucking
- Trucking
- Public Sector
- Public Sector
- Commercial Real Estate
- Commercial Real Estate
- Dealer Finance
- Dealer Finance
- Professional Services
- Professional Services
- Media
- Oil & Gas Services
- Retail & Wholesale Distribution
- Technology Banking
- Manufacturing
- Manufacturing
- Media
- Oil & Gas Services
- Retail & Wholesale Distribution
- Technology Banking
- Private Equity Sponsors
- Private Equity Sponsors
- Healthcare
- Healthcare
- Franchise Finance
- Franchise Finance
- Business Properties
- Business Properties
- Cannabis & Emerging Industries
- Cannabis & Emerging Industries
-
We Can Help
- Business Strategy
- Business Strategy
- Equipment Financing & Leasing
- Equipment Financing & Leasing
- Manage Cash Flow
- Manage Cash Flow
- Economic Insights
- Economic Insights
- Doing Business in the U.S.
- Doing Business in the U.S.
- Doing Business Internationally
- Doing Business Internationally
- Asset Based Lending
- Asset Based Lending
- Loan Syndication & Agency Services
- Loan Syndication & Agency Services
- Finance Growth
- Finance Growth
- Manage Risk
- Manage Risk
- Mergers & Acquisitions
- Mergers & Acquisitions
- Subordinated Debt-Equity
- Subordinated Debt-Equity
- Wealth Management
- Wealth Management
- Climate Smart
- Climate Smart
-
Our Bankers
![phone hover icon](https://commercial.bmo.com/static/images/phone-hover.png)
![email hover icon](https://commercial.bmo.com/static/images/mail_hover%402x.png)
![phone hover icon](https://commercial.bmo.com/static/images/phone_hover%402x.jpg)
![email icon](https://commercial.bmo.com/static/images/mail_icon_circle_hover.png)
![phone icon](https://commercial.bmo.com/static/images/phone_icon_circle_hover.png)
![share icon](https://commercial.bmo.com/static/images/share_icon_circle_hover.png)
Banking products are subject to approval and are provided in Canada by Bank of Montreal, a CDIC Member.
BMO Commercial Bank is a trade name used in Canada by Bank of Montreal, a CDIC member.
Please note important disclosures for content produced by BMO Capital Markets. BMO Capital Markets Regulatory | BMOCMC Fixed Income Commentary Disclosure | BMOCMC FICC Macro Strategy Commentary Disclosure | Research Disclosure Statements
BMO Capital Markets is a trade name used by BMO Financial Group for the wholesale banking businesses of Bank of Montreal, BMO Bank N.A. (member FDIC), Bank of Montreal Europe p.l.c., and Bank of Montreal (China) Co. Ltd, the institutional broker dealer business of BMO Capital Markets Corp. (Member FINRA and SIPC) and the agency broker dealer business of Clearpool Execution Services, LLC (Member FINRA and SIPC) in the U.S. , and the institutional broker dealer businesses of BMO Nesbitt Burns Inc. (Member Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization and Member Canadian Investor Protection Fund) in Canada and Asia, Bank of Montreal Europe p.l.c. (authorised and regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland) in Europe and BMO Capital Markets Limited (authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority) in the UK and Australia and carbon credit origination, sustainability advisory services and environmental solutions provided by Bank of Montreal, BMO Radicle Inc., and Carbon Farmers Australia Pty Ltd. (ACN 136 799 221 AFSL 430135) in Australia.
The material contained in articles posted on this website is intended as a general market commentary. The opinions, estimates and projections, if any, contained in these articles are those of the authors and may differ from those of other BMO Commercial Bank employees and affiliates. BMO Commercial Bank endeavors to ensure that the contents have been compiled or derived from sources that it believes to be reliable and which it believes contain information and opinions which are accurate and complete. However, the authors and BMO Commercial Bank take no responsibility for any errors or omissions and do not guarantee their accuracy or completeness. These articles are for informational purposes only.
Bank of Montreal and its affiliates do not provide tax, legal or accounting advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only, and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, tax, legal or accounting advice. You should consult your own tax, legal and accounting advisors before engaging in any transaction.
Third party web sites may have privacy and security policies different from BMO. Links to other web sites do not imply the endorsement or approval of such web sites. Please review the privacy and security policies of web sites reached through links from BMO web sites.
Please note important disclosures for content produced by BMO Capital Markets. BMO Capital Markets Regulatory | BMOCMC Fixed Income Commentary Disclosure | BMOCMC FICC Macro Strategy Commentary Disclosure | Research Disclosure Statements